The Ones Who Live spent a large part of the series hyping up the Echelon briefing, but The Walking Dead already revealed the twist three years ago.
The Echelon Briefing was one of the biggest mysteries in The Walking Dead: The Ones Who Live, but the franchise already revealed its big twist three years ago. With the CRM being one of Rick’s biggest Walking Dead villains, their intimidation came largely from the mystery around what made the group so powerful. While it was made clear they had large numbers and advanced technology, they didn’t do a lot of killing on-screen, making their villainous side all the more intriguing. The Echelon Briefing helped answer some of the questions surrounding the CRM, but their evil twist was nothing new.
Given the Echelon Briefing turned Thorne from a potential CRM rebel to a loyal soldier, it seemed like there would be some huge revelations to come from the briefing. Thorne even tried killing Michonne in The Ones Who Live episode 3 and attempted to foil the protagonists’ plan in the finale, showing just how much Beale’s speech won her over. However, while there was some big information and important context provided in the Echelon Briefing, The Walking Dead already gave away the big twist three years prior, making the weeks of build-up feel a little anti-climactic.
We Already Knew The CRM Destroyed Omaha (& Wanted To Destroy Portland)
World Beyond Already Revealed The Ones Who Live’s Big Twist
During the finale, The Ones Who Live revealed that the CRM destroyed Omaha and intended to destroy Portland, but this was already mentioned in World Beyond. While the Echelon Briefing did explain important new details like the CRM having spies in other communities and their belief that humanity only had 14 years left to live, their impending assault on Portland was the biggest takeaway. The concept of the CRM destroying their own community is the twisted side that has been missing from the antagonists, but World Beyond already showcased these plans and the Omaha attack three years ago.
World Beyond previously explained the CRM’s Walking Dead plan, meaning the Echelon Briefing simply reiterated what observant fans already knew. The spinoff showed the CRM wiping out Omaha and its Campus colony with chlorine gas, proving how deadly their attacks could be. Despite Omaha being allies, the CRM wanted to get rid of them. They believed Omaha could be a burden, and after taking them out, they set their sights on Portland. The Ones Who Live adds context as to why the CRM wanted to destroy their allies, but the big Echelon twist didn’t come as a surprise after World Beyond.
The Ones Who Live Put Too Much Stock Into Its Echelon Briefing Twist
The Echelon Briefing Twist Lacked Much Impact Because Of World Beyond
Although the Echelon Briefing did serve a big purpose in the finale, The Ones Who Live put too much stock into it. If the briefing had some big moral dilemma that genuinely made Rick second guess taking down the CRM, it may have warranted the hype, but reiterating the same objective as World Beyond was a let-down. Rick was never going to join Beale’s mission of slaughtering innocent communities and, while the idea of humanity having 14 years left to live was interesting, there was no real evidence behind this claim to make Rick change his mind.
The Ones Who Live and World Beyond had the same big reveal, which killed the hype around the Echelon Briefing and turned it into wasted potential.
Rick didn’t even seem worried about this during the finale, making it practically irrelevant. Instead, The Ones Who Live and World Beyond had the same big reveal, which killed the hype around the Echelon Briefing and turned it into wasted potential. The Echelon Briefing didn’t really change anything about the finale, nor did it explain why so many soldiers were committed to the plan. Instead, it gave Rick a very simple way to kill Beale, which would have been far more challenging if they weren’t alone together, proving that the briefing hurt the finale more than it helped it.
